Want to buy an ice cream maker? It’s a great idea – and one you can use for a long time. There are many reasons to have your own machine. Best of all, you can make hundreds of different frozen desserts, just the way you like them.
But what is the best ice cream maker for you? There are many different types, at different prices. And that can be quite confusing when you are just starting out. This is complicated by online reviews. Most reviewers have never used the machines they recommend! Some may have used them once or twice.
Some may have even used them once or twice. Yet they don’t seem to know how to get the most out of what they’re doing or the ice cream makers they’re testing. So we get conflicting, confusing, and totally wrong reports on the same ice cream maker.
Best Ice Cream Maker with Compressor
What type of ice cream maker is right for you?
The first step is to decide which type of ice cream maker best suits your needs – there are only three types, so choosing should be easy.
Ice and Salt Ice Cream Makers
This is how they made ice cream! You fill a container with ice and salt and freeze it.
Ice and salt machines make delicious ice cream. They can produce ice cream as good, and sometimes even better, than the other two types. However, they are not suitable for everyday use in the home kitchen.
You need a lot of ice and rock salt. And it’s very messy. If you want to make ice cream occasionally for parties or barbecues, this is the perfect choice.
However, this guide is specifically for ice cream makers for everyday use, so we don’t intend to feature any others in this article.
Ice cream freezer bowls
These machines have a removable bowl that you need to pre-cool in your freezer for at least six hours.
The bowl contains a special gel that is chilled in the freezer and transfers its coldness to the ice cream mixture when it is then stirred in the machine.
Advantages of freezer bowl machines
First of all, they are much more compact than other ice cream makers. This makes them more suitable for small kitchens and much easier to store.
And another (very important) reason is that they are cheap to buy and easy to maintain, as they use relatively basic technology.
You can buy them for very little money and be sure they will last for many years.
Disadvantages of freezer bowl machines
First of all, the bowls must be chilled in the freezer for at least six hours before being used. This requires advance preparation.
Second, you need space for the bowl in the freezer. And they are not small. Different models have different bowl sizes, so check the dimensions.
You can’t make ice cream more than once, as the bowls are pre-frozen before use. However, unless you buy another bowl and have room in your freezer for two bowls.
Compressor Ice Machines
A built-in compressor churns and cools the ice as it is churned.
To make it, simply add the ingredients to the ice cream maker and press the button. It’s very easy.
Advantages of compressor ice cream
The most convenient and flexible ice cream maker. Just remember to put the bowl in the freezer the night before.
You can start making homemade gelato, sorbet or ice cream whenever you feel like it. And once the first batch is done, you can immediately start making the next batch.
It has more features and options than other machines. Some can be optimized for ice cream, gelato and sorbet. Some are programmed to pre-chill the bowl.
Some automatically shut off when the ice cream is ready. Others keep the product at the right temperature and consistency for a period of time after it is finished.
Disadvantages of compressor machines
They are large and heavy. So they will certainly look attractive on your countertop, but make sure you have enough space!
And despite their size, they don’t have a huge capacity. They don’t make larger quantities than freezer bowl ice cream makers.
Compressor vs. freezer bowl machines
Compressor machines are larger, heavier and more expensive.
And of course, with built-in compressors and complex electronics, there can be more problems. So it’s more important to check the warranty and service.
Compressor ice cream makers are also the most expensive home machines. But convenience comes at a price.
Best Ice Cream Maker with Compressor | Comparison Table 2023
Top Quality | 5 Star Pick | Great Price
|Whynter ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Stainless Steel, Built-in Compressor, no pre-Freezing, LCD Digital Display, Timer||Whynter||Check Price|
|Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Freezer Storage Containers (4-Pack) Bundle (3 Items)||Cuisinart||Check Price|
|Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker, Stainless - 110/120V 60 HZ||Musso||Check Price|
|Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker, Brushed Stainless Steel||Breville||Check Price|
|Cuisinart ICE-60W Cool Creations Ice Cream Maker, White & ICE-70RFB Replacement Freezer Bowl, 2 quart, Gray||Cuisinart||Check Price|
|Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker, 4 Quart, White||Hamilton Beach||Check Price|
|Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker, for Gelato, Mix-ins, Milkshakes, Sorbet, Smoothie Bowls & More, 7 One-Touch Programs, with (2) Pint Containers & Lids, Compact Size, Perfect for Kids, Silver||Ninja||Check Price|
|KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment - Excludes 7, 8, and most 6 Quart Models, Fits 5 to 6 quart Mixers||KitchenAid||Check Price|
|Whynter ICM-201SB Upright Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Built-in Compressor, no pre-Freezing, LCD Digital Display, Timer, Stainless Steel Mixing Bowl, 2.1||Whynter||Check Price|
Best Ice Cream Maker with Compressor | Reviews 2023
The Whynter ICM-200LS is a 2-quart stainless steel automatic ice cream maker that is ideal for entertaining. With a 4.5 out of 5-star rating on Amazon and the “Amazon’s Choice” designation, this machine is a top choice for those looking to make delicious homemade ice cream. The machine is equipped with a powerful built-in compressor freezer, allowing for continuous use without the need for pre-freezing the mixing bowl. This makes the process of creating gelato, ice cream, sorbet, or all-natural yogurt quick and convenient.
The machine is designed with safety in mind, featuring an extended cooling function that prevents ice cream from melting and a motor protection function that stops the motor from churning once the mixture solidifies, preventing overheating or damage. The sleek stainless steel exterior and soft touch LCD control panel make this ice cream maker a stylish addition to any kitchen counter.
The Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Freezer Storage Containers Bundle is an excellent choice for those who want to make their own frozen treats at home. The bundle includes the Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, as well as two ChefWave 1 pt Reusable Ice Cream Storage Containers with Silicone Lids. This bundle provides everything you need to get started making your own ice cream, gelato, and other frozen desserts.
The Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream and Gelato Maker features a commercial-quality compressor-freezer, so it's always ready to go. It has separate paddles for gelato and ice cream, and fully automatic operation with a 60-minute countdown timer, ensuring perfect consistencies and professional results.
The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker is a high-quality appliance designed to make delicious ice cream and sorbet. This stainless steel machine has a 1-1/2-quart capacity bowl that can freeze up to 3 quarts of frozen confection per hour. It's fully automatic and comes with two buttons to control the operation, as well as a timer that can be set for different frozen confection types. The housing, bowl, and paddle of the machine are made of stainless steel for easy cleaning, and it measures 12 inches wide, 11 inches high, and 18 inches deep. It weighs 38 pounds and is made in Italy.
This product has received great ratings from customers, who appreciate its ease of use, the great flavor it produces, and the quality of the materials used. The only downside to this machine is the noise level, which some customers find a little high. However, overall, this is a great machine that can produce fantastic ice cream and sorbet. Keep in mind that products with electrical plugs are designed for use in the US, and may require an adapter or converter for use in other countries. Make sure to check compatibility before purchasing.
The Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker is a premium quality ice cream machine with a brushed stainless steel finish. It has a capacity of 1.5 quarts and is made of durable stainless steel material. The machine is equipped with 12 hardness settings, making it possible to make sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream with ease. The self-refrigerating compressor operates on 110 to 120 volts and has a power output of 165 watts.
The machine has both fully automatic and manual functionality, with a keep cool setting that can maintain the ideal temperature for up to 3 hours. The pre-cool setting allows the machine to reach the optimal operating temperature quickly. The removable bowl, paddle, and cleaning brush make cleaning a breeze, while the instruction booklet provides set up and user guidance. According to customer ratings, the Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker is easy to use, produces great-tasting ice cream, is easy to clean, and has good durability. Please note that this product is designed for use in the US, and may require an adapter or converter for use in other countries.
The Cuisinart ICE-60W Cool Creations Ice Cream Maker and the ICE-70RFB Replacement Freezer Bowl are a bundle package that allows you to make 2 quarts of delicious ice cream. The ice cream maker features a 2-quart capacity and an improved paddle that processes ingredients faster. The control panel has three settings with multiple speeds, and an ingredient spout with an integrated measuring cup makes it easy to add ingredients.
The double-insulated freezer bowl holds up to 2 quarts of ice cream and functions as a replacement item or second bowl. You won't have to stir the ingredients or add ice, as the bowl maintains a low temperature that freezes ingredients fast and evenly. It is important to note that the freezer bowl only fits the Cuisinart ICE-70 ice cream maker and that products with electrical plugs are designed for use in the US, so compatibility should be checked before purchasing.
The Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker is a versatile and convenient kitchen appliance that allows you to create a variety of frozen desserts in your own home. With a 4-quart capacity, it is perfect for families and special occasions. The fully automatic design means that you won't have to spend hours stirring your ice cream mixture - simply add your ingredients, ice and rock salt, and the machine will do all the work for you, stopping automatically when your dessert is ready.
The Hamilton Beach 68330N Ice Cream Maker is also very easy to use, thanks to its simple, intuitive design. The easy-lock lid fits securely onto the top of the machine, and can be locked in place with a quick turn. This ensures that your ice cream mixture will stay perfectly chilled, without any leaks or spills. The machine also comes with over 20 delicious recipes, so you can try your hand at creating classic frozen treats like ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard, sorbet, gelato and sherbet.
The Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker is a compact, yet versatile kitchen appliance that allows you to transform everyday ingredients into a wide array of frozen treats. With 7 one-touch programs, it's easy for everyone in the family to enjoy making ice cream, gelato, smoothie bowls, milkshakes, and more. This machine features the innovative Creamify Technology that finely shaves and churns ice particles into creamy frozen treats in minutes, giving you complete control over the flavor and texture of your frozen treats.
The Ninja CREAMi is also compact in size, making it easy to store and fitting perfectly on your countertop. You can mix in your favorite ingredients like chocolate, nuts, candy, fruit, and more to personalize your frozen treats. The 7 versatile programs, including Ice Cream, Sorbet, Gelato, Milkshake, Smoothie Bowl, Lite Ice Cream, and Mix-In, allow you to choose the perfect combination of speed, pressure, and time to create the perfect treat. The Re-Spin function allows you to soften and cream up your treat after processing if needed. The machine comes with a motor base with dual-drive motors, a creamerizer paddle, 2 16 oz. CREAMi pints with storage lids, an outer bowl and lid to house the pint while processing, and a recipe inspiration guide with 30 recipes. The containers, lids, and paddle are also top-rack dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment is a product designed for use with KitchenAid stand mixers. It is compatible with 5 to 6 quart mixers, excluding 7 and 8 quart models, and most 6 quart models. This attachment is made of plastic and has a manual special feature. It allows you to make up to 2 quarts of ice cream, gelato, or sorbet in 20-30 minutes with the dasher rotating inside the bowl to spread, scrape, and mix the ingredients thoroughly.
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment is easy to clean with warm soapy water and some tilt-head models may require an adapter ring to fit properly. The package includes a freeze bowl, dasher, and drive assembly, which work together powered by the stand mixer. You simply pour the batter into the bowl and let the dasher and freeze bowl do the work. The dasher, drive assembly, and adapter ring are dishwasher safe, while the freeze bowl should be hand washed. Measuring 10-8/9 by 10-2/7 by 10-2/7 inches, this product comes with a 1-year hassle-free replacement warranty.
The Whynter ICM-201SB is an electric ice cream maker with a 2.1 quart capacity. It is ideal for entertaining as it can make up to 2 quarts of your favorite frozen dessert in a single batch. This allows you to fully customize the taste of your homemade ice cream, sorbet, gelato, or frozen yogurt. With a powerful built-in compressor freezer, the machine allows for continuous use without the inconvenience of pre-freezing the stainless steel mixing bowl.
The ice cream maker is safe and easy to use, with an extended cooling function that prevents the ice cream from melting and a motor protection function that stops the motor from churning to prevent overheating or damage once the mixture solidifies. The modern design of the machine boasts a small footprint and a sleek, food-safe stainless steel exterior that is designed to complement any kitchen counter. The Whynter ICM-201SB is a versatile and convenient way to make delicious homemade ice cream from the comfort of your own home.
How To Pick The Best Ice Cream Maker with Compressor | Ultimate Guide 2023
About the material
At this time, plastic is generally not a good material for structures. Indeed, they are very fragile and can deteriorate over time. You need to go for high quality materials that are strong and can stand the test of time.
Aluminum is generally a good material. It keeps the ice cold and transfers it more quickly into the composition. It also holds moisture very well.
When using machines for making cheap ice cream at a specific level as well as at a commercial level, it is advisable to choose a transparent lid. This will make it easier to follow what is going on inside.
For example, you will know exactly how long you are preparing an ice cream. For example, you will know exactly how long it takes to prepare the ice cream, when to add the different ingredients and other relevant details.
Frequency of use
The first thing to evaluate when choosing a machine is how often you will use it. For example, if you only use it occasionally, there is no need to invest in a less powerful machine.
If you are going to make ice cream for a large family, you should choose a model that can make about 4 to 6 liters of ice cream.
Self-refrigerating or non-refrigerating
You must choose between self-cooling and non-self-cooling models. Self-cooling models are equipped with a container that can be cooled while the blade is moving. Non-cooling machines, on the other hand, require the container to be kept in the freezer for several hours before use.
Self-chilling machines are suitable for people who make ice cream frequently, while non-chilling machines are suitable for people who rarely eat ice cream. Another difference is that non-refrigerated machines are less expensive. They are lighter and take up less space.
However, self-cooling systems have more advantages. One is that the bowls do not necessarily need to be cooled before use. This not only reduces production time. It also allows ice cream to be prepared several times in a row, while consuming less energy. In any case, these are expensive machines that require a lot of space and have a significant environmental impact.
In the unlikely event that you decide to choose a non-refrigerated model, you should check how long it takes to cool the container. What are also the dimensions of the latter, because there is not always space in the freezer.
Ice cream makers have an average capacity of 270 ml to 2 liters at a time, with most ranging from 1 to 1.5 liters.
Most ice cream makers can make ice cream in quantity. So you need to consider how much ice cream you want to make at one time.
The recipe book that comes with the machine should have the appropriate quantities. It is important to follow the recommended volume.
If you fill the container to the brim, you will end up with all the ice cream on the work surface when the ice cream starts to freeze and expand. If you are using other recipes as a guide, adjust the optimal amount so that the ice cream does not overflow.
However, some ice cream machines do not tell you how much ice cream they can make. This means that you just have to follow their recipe. Make sure you understand the amount of ice cream they produce and adjust it for your own use.
Ease of cleaning
The appliance will get dirty. And if debris, especially dairy, is not removed, it can be completely damaged. So you need an ice cream maker that is easy to clean. It should be able to be disassembled into parts: the container on the one hand, the lid and blades on the other.
Some of them can be washed in a dishwasher, which is more convenient. With these, there is no need to worry about cleaning other than disassembly and assembly.
Have you ever thought about where you want to place your machine? This is an important point. For example, if you choose a model with a large compression capacity, you will need a lot of space for storage, especially if you place it on a work surface. Also, if you choose a model that takes up a lot of space, the storage options become more complicated.
Have you ever put together a "team" of appliances to take advantage of the limited space you have in your closet or on your workbench? Well, there is a considerable difference in the size of each model.
The smaller models have a similar footprint to a kettle. But the larger ones can be as large as a food processor. Some ice cream makers are almost as large in diameter as a dish. However, before you buy, make sure the container for these machines fits your freezer.
Self-refrigerating ice cream makers, on the other hand, are usually large, bulky, heavy and difficult to move.
Everyone likes ice cream, but not everyone likes the noise of a machine. This criterion is more related to the place of use. For commercial use, noise may not be a major issue. However, there should be a limit to the noise made by ice cream and gelato machines for home use.
Regardless of the type of machine, the noise decibel should not exceed 65-70 dB. Anything above this threshold is not safe for the human ear, especially over long periods of time.
When ordering, many vendors list noise levels that are not particularly high. However, if you can't find this detail, ask the seller!
Machines without compressor
There are two main types of ice cream makers: those with a built-in refrigeration system (compressor, condenser, expansion valve and evaporator) and those without. Most of the latter are equipped with a removable, insulated bowl containing a hermetically sealed refrigerant. Like blocks of ice in a cooler, this bowl must be left in the freezer overnight to allow the liquid refrigerant to freeze.
Ice cream makers without refrigeration tend to be less expensive than those with refrigeration. The main drawback is that you can't make multiple batches or different flavors in a row, unless you buy a second bowl. You are limited to making one batch of ice cream/gelato/sorbet and then have to clean up overnight and freeze the bowl before you can make a second batch (I discuss this drawback in more detail below). Ice cream makers without built-in refrigeration also tend to produce ice cream and gelato that is not as smooth and creamy as those produced by ice cream makers with built-in refrigeration.
What is the best type of ice cream maker?
Everyone thinks that a high-end ice cream maker with a built-in compressor is the best choice for making ice cream at home. This is because, in addition to the excellent quality of the ice cream produced, it is a very convenient method in terms of time and effort.
How long should ice cream makers freeze?
This depends on the type of ice cream maker and the temperature of your freezer. The instructions that come with our Top Pick - Cuisinart ICE-21-Cole ice cream maker call for freezing at 0°F (-18°C) for 16 to 24 hours. This means you need to plan your ice cream making efforts accordingly, but it's worth waiting for the bowl to freeze properly to bring out the rich, creamy texture that best defines great ice cream.
Is an ice cream maker worth it?
If you love ice cream and have the space in your kitchen to accommodate an ice cream maker, then yes, it is worth it! Using an ice cream maker takes time. Using an ice cream maker takes some planning and patience, but once you master the machine and the basic techniques of ice cream making, you can get started with combinations of flavors and ingredients to add.
Can I make ice cream without an ice cream maker?
Some recipes don't require an ice cream maker, but don't be surprised if the texture doesn't change much. You can make it with a whisk or stand mixer, but it's no substitute for ice cream made in a properly cooled ice cream maker.
Final thoughts on the best ice cream makers
The best ice cream maker for you will depend on the level of convenience you're looking for, how much money you have to spend, and how you personally weigh the pros and cons of each machine.
If you want to know which home ice cream makers produce the best quality ice cream, gelato, sorbet and frozen yogurt, you're in the clear.
Hi, I’m Jennifer Lawrence, Went to Calhoun High School (Georgia) my goal is to make the kitchen fun by providing a mathematical and logical component to our approach to cooking good food. I look not only at delicious recipes but also at kitchen tools and gadgets to give you the tips and tricks we hope you will find useful. Read More Here